Forest list archive: msg00008

[Prev][Next][Index][Thread]

Re: Sustainable Forest Management Roundtables



On 12/1/95, Nelson Wong writes:

> The question here is not whether old-growth forests are a renewable
> resource but whether timber by itself is a renewable resource. Secondly, if

While I can appreciate the fact that this may not be an issue for you, it
is most certainly an issue for many of us here in the states, and is
certainly an issue for me personally when a mere 50 miles from my house
healthy, green, 600 and 700 year old trees are being cut under the
auspices of "forest health" by reducing fire risk.  Now I admit that I'm
not a forester, but I do know that when a fire burns through a forest, it
is usually the smaller trees and the underbrush that burn, not the big
trees with 10-14" cambiums.  The reason these healthy old giants are
falling is because they're valuable, not because Boise Cascade et al. are
concerned about "forest health."  Most people I know (including myself as
I'm a carpenter when I'm not in school) firmly beleive is sustainable
wood products.  What is a constant rallying point for us "eco-terrorists"
is the destruction of the last 5% or so of our native forests *that are
on public lands*  Why the industry doesn't realize this, and back off,
I'll never understand.  I guess it's called greed.

> step further, what about plastics eg. PVCs for that matter. Are metals
> and plastics bio-degradeble ? Are they environmental friendly ? Are metal
> ores renewable and sustainable ? If not, which would one prefers to use ?
> Metals and plastics, or, timber ? Answers please.

No, most metals and plastics can be recycled and thus reused.  Does the
timber industry make any effort to recycle wood products (other than
paper)?  As a contracter, it is very frustrating to fill a 20 yd dumpster
with perfectly good 2x4's etc. that can't be reused ala building codes
that don't permit it.  The industry has consistatly fought efforts to
rewrite the building codes to allow for the use of "used lumber."  After
all, they only profit on virgin materials.

Bret Diamond
diam9018@tao.sosc.osshe.edu
Oregon, USA



Follow-Ups: References:

[Metla] [Main Index] [Thread Index]

Mail converted by MHonArc 1.1.0